Bud Black Needs a Lesson in Probability; Baseball

| | Comments (3)

The National League wild card race will probably be as close this season as it was last season; the Diamondbacks, Dodgers, Rockies, Padres, Mets, Braves and Phillies all have a chance to win 90 games. So Padres manager Bud Black isn't taking any chances in case there is a tie at the end of the year like there was in 2007. He's holding coin-tossing practice:

"Toward the end of a recent media session, Black pulled out a quarter and told general manager Kevin Towers to practice. Black then began flipping the coin, with Towers calling heads all four times. The first two were tails; the latter two were tails. Last season, Towers called heads for all but one coin toss to determine the site of potential one-game, tiebreaker playoffs. The one time he called tails resulted in the Padres going to Denver, where they lost to the Rockies in a one-game playoff."

Um, Bud...you realize that a coin toss is a discrete-time stochastic process that cannot be predicted and more importantly cannot be practiced. Worst of all, Bud, you're stuck in the Monte Carlo fallacy. The probability of an event in a random sequence is not dependent on preceding events! I think I still have my college probability textbook at home if you'd like to peruse it sometime. (full disclosure: there are doodles of naked chicks in the margins)

Perhaps Major League Baseball should get rid of the coin-toss completely and replace it with Rock, Paper, Scissors. Now that's a contest that requires some practice and skill.

PREVIOUS: Conditioning With Kosuke Fukudome   |   NEXT: Site News: Hear Your Pals on Internet Radio


If you don't drill, you can't win. Remember when Brian Sabean panicked at the coin flip in '98 and shouted, "ZAMBONI!"? The Giants lost the play-in game at Wrigley and the rest was history. True-ish story.

I think they should do Rock Em Sock Em Robots.

Everybody knows you call tails everytime.

Tails never fails.

Leave a comment