Ken Rosenthal Should Never Use the Word 'Shortcomings'

| | Comments (6)

The 2009 Atlanta Braves will always be remembered as a team that was built on a strong foundation of starting pitching and destroyed with a bulldozer driven by manager Bobby Cox. At least that's what FOX sideline princess Ken Rosenthal would have you think. See, the Braves offense was about as productive as a neutered four-point buck this season and Rosensquirrel fingers Bobby as the culprit in a column entitled, "You can blame Cox for Atlanta's shortcomings".

Yes, Ken Rosenthal used the word "shortcomings":

Perhaps the better question is: Did Cox push too hard with his team's two best sluggers, catcher Brian McCann and third baseman Chipper Jones?

The evidence suggests yes.

The Braves' chances of reaching the postseason all but ended when they went 1-6 between Sept. 2 and 9. McCann was 1-for-25 during that stretch, Jones 2-for-20 with two walks.

It's not as if Cox lacked quality alternatives for both players -- he had Omar Infante and Martin Prado for Jones, David Ross for Martin. It's just that, like most managers, he sticks with the players he trusts most -- and the relievers he trusts most, too.

If I was a baseball manager and my general manager had given me two productive bats and a collection of has-beens and never-will-bes to work with, I'm not sure I'd have the spine to bench my two best players no matter how badly they were slumping.

Sure, Bobby Cox is the captain of the U.S.S Animatronic Cow and like all good captains should go down with his ship. But it's not fair for Rosenthal to call him out for not handling his offense well; Cox had barely a shred of offense to work with!

Also, notice that Rosenthal suggests playing David Ross instead of "Martin" and not "McCann". Martin is the stud catcher in Los Angeles. Chalk that one up to a mental error. Still, play Ken Rosenthal off, Matthew Kaminski.

PREVIOUS: You There! Spend Your Lunch Break Listening to Three Guys Yak   |   NEXT: Miller Park Drunk Sells Out to Corporate Overlords from Chicago


Rosensquirrel's argument is invalid for a few reasons. A) Prado has been the teams starting 2b since Late June/Early July, because Bobby replaced the absolutely ineffective Kelly Johnson.

B) Bobby can only play the players he had and Frenchy and Schaffer left two gaping holes in the line up for the first half of the year.

C) While I agree CJ should have been moved down in the order or given a few more days off, McCann is the best hitter on the team, you think he should be playing less, to win the WC?

D) The Braves' chances of reaching the postseason all but ended when they went 1-6 between Sept. 2 and 9. McCann was 1-for-25 during that stretch, Jones 2-for-20 with two walks Small Sample Size - something Ken should be familiar with.



Seven whole games! That's a good sample size for football. One problem: this ain't football, Kenny. Seven games = 4.32% of a baseball schedule.

And Infante was out with an injury until August and hasn't returned to form yet.

Maybe Ken meant to write "You Can't Blame Bobby Cox For Braves Shortcoming" because that thesis statement would have more facts to back it up.

I wish I got paid to completely screw up like that...

Wait, I thought everyone was in agreement that players win and lose baseball games and seasons, not managers. Huh.

Leave a comment